← All Texts
Dissertation

Peter Kislinger PhD Dissertation / Abstract: “Some Truths seem almost Falsehoods and some Falsehoods almost Truths”. Narrative technique, mise-en-abyme and intertextuality,constructive irony and the truth of fiction in Anthony Powell's A Dance To The Music of Time. Wien 1993 (419 pp.)

First published: 1993
Author: Peter Kislinger
Title: “Some Truths seem almost Falsehoods and some Falsehoods almost Truths”. Narrative technique, mise-en-abyme and intertextuality,constructive irony and the truth of fiction in Anthony Powell's A Dance To The Music of Time. (419 pp.)
Degree: PhD University: University of Vienna (Austria)
Year: 1993
Abstract:

Drawing on Gérard Genette's “Narrative Discourse“, Franz K. Stanzel's “A Theory of Narrative“, and Wolfgang Iser's “The Act of Reading“, this study of A Dance to the Music of Time takes a unified approach to narrative techniques, themes, motifs, and imagery.

Powell plays upon the admiring and ironic interactional modalities of aesthetic and ethical identification with the 'hero'. Among other influences, Schopenhauer's theory of history and fiction and Nietzsche's criticism of the correspondence theory of truth are identified as formative on Powell's theory of truth. The fragmentation of the implied poetics of the novel is considered an original and creative response to Nietzsche's challenging perspectivism and aesthetics. The mise-en-abymes (i.e. the inherent poetics) draw on various metaphorical sources and recycle the history of the self-reflexive novel. Rather than relying on just one model, Powell's mise-en-abymes draw on different metaphorical sources, adopting (and even parodying) the history of the self-reflexive novel from different perspectives. As the narrating act becomes more complex, so too does the poetics, mirroring the growth of the “experiencing self“.

Aesthetic notions and motifs borrowed from early Cubism compensate for the restrictions of the first-person narrative and counteract doctrinal and metaphysical conceptions of truth. This study analyses and evaluates the manifold thematic functions of the complex interrelationships between discourse and story. Drawing on Iser's “structure of theme and horizon“, the study demonstrates that the “meaning“ of the narrating act cannot be understood in a single-dimensional way. Jenkins's (the narrating self´s) discourse must be assessed according to the “horizon“ of thematically related segments and the “horizon“ of the novel's fragmented inherent poetics.

Quotations from hermetic, especially alchemical, traditions indirectly relate the growth of the experiencing self and allegorise the creative act. Alongside four motif patterns, they serve as structuring devices. Powell shows that astrology and alchemy, together with mythological, biblical, Christian, Gnostic and mainstream European philosophical traditions, are devoid of any transcendental meaning.

Stereotypical metaphors and motifs are recycled and given new thematic and structural functions. Mosaics, collages, jigsaw puzzles, kaleidoscopes and alchemical and Greek mythological imagery – as well as the myth of Isis and Osiris – are employed, with a nod to contemporary Nouveau Roman theories, not only as models for the narrative act (the dichotomy of fragmentation and totality), but also to reflect the destructive element of time and humanity's attempt to come to terms with its effects.

In epiphanies, the experiencing self arrives at notions that are central to European thought. Although Powell, does not deny the possibility of individual growth, the text remains sceptical about the notion of linear development. A Dance to the Music of Time forces the reader to find answers deriving from its structure; however, it cannot offer such answers without betraying its ideology of self-autonomy.

German title
"Some Truths seem almost Falsehoods and some Falsehoods almost Truths." |Erzähltechnik, romaninhärente Poetik und intertextuelles Erzählen als "konstruktiv-ironische" Demonstration der Wahrheit des Romans in Anthony Powells A Dance To The Music of Time. Dissertation zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades an der geisteswissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität Wien 1993 (419 pp.)